The tricky thing I find about these matchups is figuring out how each of the characters would end up duking it out. The main reason for this I find, is that when it comes to DC characters a lot of things end up as a fist fight, and thus most of the DC characters have superhuman strength, whereas a large portion of the Marvel characters do not. Superman was a particularly difficult subject to find a matchup for, since he is so strong. I'm certain that there beings equally "powerful" as Superman in the Marvel universe, say perhaps some of the more powerful beings like Magneto or Graviton, I had even considered Silver Surfer to be an adequate matchup against the Man of Steel, however, when considering that this matchup would ultimately degenerate into a fist fight, I needed to find a balance in strength as well as compensating for his other powers. The original matchup had Superman pitted against the Incredible Hulk, which is understandable, as Hulk feasibly has no upper limit to his strength. However, I believe that I've found a more appropriate adversary in Gladiator from the Shi'ar Empire, whose abilities do match that of Superman's.
Saturday, July 23, 2011
Marvel vs. DC Redux Matchup #1: Batman vs. Punisher
So now we get started. Logic would dictate that perhaps Bruce Wayne (Batman) is perhaps more comparable a matchup to Tony Stark (Iron Man), both being extraordinarily rich entrepreneur types (Wayne Enterprises and Stark Industry), no powers so to speak, and nifty gadgets (though with Iron Man most of his gadgets are built into his suit), but in all honesty, Batman as a detective type character was never one to rely on technology whereas Iron Man as a character is almost solely based on technology. Thus I decided that instead a better matchup for the renown detective of Gotham would perhaps be the vigilante cop Frank Castle, a.k.a. the Punisher. I figure two vigilante justice type folks would provide an interesting matchup.
Friday, July 22, 2011
Marvel vs. DC Redux
So I know I've been posting a lot of random more "profound" things lately, and decided I wanted to lighten things up a bit. In 1996 there was a crossover between two major comic book companies, DC and Marvel. Now at this point in time, I might have totally geeked out on a majority of my reading audience, which I suppose is small enough to either be really hard (to reach a majority), or really easy, in that I'm really geeking out. Anyways, I figure, I've been rethinking it, and there are some matchups I'd like to explore. The original crossover featured the following matchups:
Hulk vs. Superman
Captain America vs. Batman
Storm vs. Wonder Woman
Wolverine vs. Lobo
Namor vs. Aquaman
Quicksilver vs. Flash
Thor vs. Captain Marvel
Jubilee vs. Robin
Spider-Man vs. Superboy
Among various other ones. While some of these are interesting, I'd like to revisit this concept with some modified matchups. Some will be the same and some will be different. These are ones I think interesting or appropriate. Of course, this is entirely my opinion so it may differ. I'm not immensely familiar with DC characters, and there's a certain degree of difficulty making appropriate matchups (in my opinion) given that DC characters have such generic abilities (flight, superhuman strength/speed, etc...). That notwithstanding, we'll give this a go. I'll post matchups one by one and give my takes on them. Feel free to completely ignore them or follow along. Cheers!
Hulk vs. Superman
Captain America vs. Batman
Storm vs. Wonder Woman
Wolverine vs. Lobo
Namor vs. Aquaman
Quicksilver vs. Flash
Thor vs. Captain Marvel
Jubilee vs. Robin
Spider-Man vs. Superboy
Among various other ones. While some of these are interesting, I'd like to revisit this concept with some modified matchups. Some will be the same and some will be different. These are ones I think interesting or appropriate. Of course, this is entirely my opinion so it may differ. I'm not immensely familiar with DC characters, and there's a certain degree of difficulty making appropriate matchups (in my opinion) given that DC characters have such generic abilities (flight, superhuman strength/speed, etc...). That notwithstanding, we'll give this a go. I'll post matchups one by one and give my takes on them. Feel free to completely ignore them or follow along. Cheers!
Thursday, July 21, 2011
Perceived Importance
Everybody's different. That's what we're always told when we're growing up. It's the reason why not everyone prefers chocolate ice cream over vanilla, why some people prefer blue to the color red, or why some people enjoy the opera and others don't. It's pretty apparent when we look at one another and talk with one another that, everyone is different. I suppose the logical question now to ask, as is the case with all of my writing (i.e. every post on this blog), is: where am I going with this? Well, I'm sure you've oft heard of how we have "luxurious problems" or have heard something regarding starving children in Africa. I'm not here to tell you that malnourished and impoverished African children aren't important. They're very important, but at the end of the day I'm not an impoverished, malnourished African child. I know that probably sounds somewhat cold and selfish, but that is reality.
Wednesday, June 29, 2011
Life by faith and by sight
"For we live by faith, not by sight."- 2 Corinthians 5:7
It's a familiar phrase, one that a lot of us have heard much before, especially those of us more involved with church and Christianity. It's a familiar verse, but what does it mean? What is faith? What does it mean to live by it? What does it mean to live by sight? My short answer to that is this: read a commentary. I'm really not here to go through and exegete this short verse. What I am here to consider is what it means now in the context of today. The apostle Paul wrote this in the context of a letter to the Corinthian church, in the context of awaiting the receipt of the new and redeemed body. I want to discuss what it is life by faith, because I would posit that we all do it, everybody. It's not a matter of whether or not we have faith but rather what we put our faith in.
Tuesday, April 19, 2011
Time Well Spent
"A new commandment I give unto you, That ye love one another; as I have loved you, that ye also love one another."
- John 13:34 (KJV)
That probably looks pretty familiar to a number of you out there, and I suppose the question is where am I going with this whole thing? Which is a legitimate question. For those of you that are familiar with it, I'm sure you have heard a number of lessons and sermons on how we ought to love one another, how we are to love as Christ loved us, how Christ has loved us, etc... So I don't know that I'm going to say anything mind-shatteringly new. I'm probably not actually. But it doesn't have to be something new to be something important. I suppose in some sense what I am discussing is "how" one loves another, but I don't want to approach it in the sense of something like The Five Love Languages by Dr. Gary Chapman. I kind of just grant that everyone needs/desires to be loved differently, which naturally leads us to the conclusion that we are to love each person differently. I suppose this gets kind of confusing at times because we so often attempt to quantify love, but just because the treatment is different is not indicative of a different "amount" of love. That's not really what I want to talk about either though. I suppose at this point I'm just kind of rambling. The aspect of love that I wish to discuss here, is the aspect of time.
Monday, February 7, 2011
Changing perspectives
I'm somewhat melancholy when it comes to this time of year. Maybe it's because I'm single. Maybe it's because all the single people are melancholy and it's become some sort of airborne contagion that single people catch. Maybe it's because the not-single people are so blatantly not melancholy. If ever there was some contrived, commercialized holiday for the sake of a holiday it's Valentine's Day. I suppose I'm just sounding bitter right now, but honestly we don't really need a special day to remember our special someone do we? I hope not. Frankly, it just seems to be there to kind of rub it in the faces of those people who don't yet have special someones, but that's not really what this post is about.
Monday, January 24, 2011
Word of the day: apotyphobia
Apotyphobia - [a-po-ti-fo-bee-a] - noun - the fear of failure (note: apparently the real word is atychiphobia)
Derived from the Greek words apotychia which means failure, and phobos which means fear, and I totally just made this word up. While the word may be something that I randomly pulled together, the concept certainly isn't something altogether foreign to us. My brother once told me that Asian children will grow up to be good at what they do but they'll never be geniuses. In the wake of the moderately controversial WSJ article by Yale professor, Amy Chua, some have attributed this to the fact that typical Asian parental methods leaves the children dispassionate and disinterested, where life is a series of duties and obligations. I would contend that the problem may lie in passion, as it's not unfeasible for someone to be brilliant at something he/she doesn't particularly like doing, but rather, apotyphobia.
I think to best illustrate I will use a personal example, hopefully, said example will not alienate too many of my readers. Growing up, I used to play a game called Bandit Kings of Ancient China, a turn-based strategy game based around the well-known Chinese story entitled Outlaws of the Marsh. The game involved building armies and attacking different territories, and ultimately you are attempting to take down the evil prime minister Gao Qiu before the year 1127 when the Northern Barbarians take over China, or something along those lines. Anyways, the point is, that when I played the game, I would always run into the time constraint, and I always wondered why. The simple reason is this: I never went to battle unless I was very sure I could win. While it meant that I could be very systematic in my battle strategies, it also meant that a lot of time passed to get to the level of comfort that I had to reach before actually attacking someone else, in short, I was afraid to lose, even in a stupid computer game that didn't matter, because it was just against the computer.
We can denote it as fear of embarrassment, being overly people-conscious, or what have you, but ultimately, all these reasons conglomerate into a fear of getting it wrong, or as I now like to call it, apotyphobia. Now, I don't know if this is strictly a generality of Asian-American kids, but I definitely think it's much more prevalent in Asian-American kids per se, because of the Asian emphasis on appearances or in more colloquial terminology, "saving face". This isn't to say that I discourage the exercise of prudence or sound judgment, but rather, an encouragement to push past what we normally consider to be our areas of comfort. I say this as much to myself as I do to anyone reading this, which a large part of why I write these things in the first place. Too many times we forgo the opportunity to engage simply because of our aversion to an adverse outcome, I'll be the first to admit that I'm typically like this. I prefer a wide margin of buffer space so that if things to go as planned, the engagement can still be deemed as having achieved some modicum of success. What I loosely term "engagement" in this instance ranges anywhere from a project to a simple conversation.
What drives this apotyphobia? Primarily, I think it's a sense of judgment. One of the worst feelings in the world is to feel condescended or patronized, at least it is for me. Growing up (and I can't say whether or not this is an Asian thing or not) I always had this unconscious sense that being incompetent is worse than being wrong. I want to say that's a line from a movie (Day After Tomorrow maybe?). This nagging certainty that when I do something, I can't look bad doing it, always pervades and thereby, highly limits what I do end up doing. As a guy, this holds true even more when dealing with girls. Maybe it's a societal thing, maybe it's a cultural thing, all I'm sure if is this, at some point in time, or rather at several (more than several) points in time, I am going to screw up, I need to grow up and live with it, ultimately, I need to learn and to grow from it.
While the world isn't really a very friendly place to screw up, the lesson to be learned from this is whether or not I'm okay if someone else screws up. Certainly, there are going to be more critical issues where it's going to be a bigger deal if a mistake is made, but can I live with it, and help the transgressor become a better person from it? My thoughts on this rest largely in the context of church. While we strive for excellence in church, I find that it also should be an environment in which we are comfortable "being human" and thereby falling short. Will it be embarrassing? Most certainly, but as a church, it should be a place where learning experiences can be brought to light from each embarrassment. In order for us to be transparent with one another as we ought to be in the body of Christ, we must trust the intentions of those around us and thereby are willing to just give it our best, regardless of the result. For every success there will be a correlating number of failures, that's how we learn what is going to be successful. Living in a fellowship of Christ doesn't mean getting everything right, but rather, loving one another, even when we get things wrong. A church in which people are afraid to "do the wrong thing" I think needs to take a closer look at the relationships that it has between its members.
I'm certainly not saying I'm okay with screwing up, I hope that people don't walk away with that impression, but rather, the very real possibility of me screwing up doesn't push me to inaction. In some sense you can think of it this way, if nothing happens you're not successful, which is essentially screwing up. It's not a matter of not wanting to get things right all the time, but a matter of being willing to risk getting things wrong. I know I'm apotyphobic, and to some degree, that might be called prudence, but taken too far and it renders me a paralytic. Seize the moment, and if failure ensues, learn from it. Some opportunities only come once.
Derived from the Greek words apotychia which means failure, and phobos which means fear, and I totally just made this word up. While the word may be something that I randomly pulled together, the concept certainly isn't something altogether foreign to us. My brother once told me that Asian children will grow up to be good at what they do but they'll never be geniuses. In the wake of the moderately controversial WSJ article by Yale professor, Amy Chua, some have attributed this to the fact that typical Asian parental methods leaves the children dispassionate and disinterested, where life is a series of duties and obligations. I would contend that the problem may lie in passion, as it's not unfeasible for someone to be brilliant at something he/she doesn't particularly like doing, but rather, apotyphobia.
I think to best illustrate I will use a personal example, hopefully, said example will not alienate too many of my readers. Growing up, I used to play a game called Bandit Kings of Ancient China, a turn-based strategy game based around the well-known Chinese story entitled Outlaws of the Marsh. The game involved building armies and attacking different territories, and ultimately you are attempting to take down the evil prime minister Gao Qiu before the year 1127 when the Northern Barbarians take over China, or something along those lines. Anyways, the point is, that when I played the game, I would always run into the time constraint, and I always wondered why. The simple reason is this: I never went to battle unless I was very sure I could win. While it meant that I could be very systematic in my battle strategies, it also meant that a lot of time passed to get to the level of comfort that I had to reach before actually attacking someone else, in short, I was afraid to lose, even in a stupid computer game that didn't matter, because it was just against the computer.
We can denote it as fear of embarrassment, being overly people-conscious, or what have you, but ultimately, all these reasons conglomerate into a fear of getting it wrong, or as I now like to call it, apotyphobia. Now, I don't know if this is strictly a generality of Asian-American kids, but I definitely think it's much more prevalent in Asian-American kids per se, because of the Asian emphasis on appearances or in more colloquial terminology, "saving face". This isn't to say that I discourage the exercise of prudence or sound judgment, but rather, an encouragement to push past what we normally consider to be our areas of comfort. I say this as much to myself as I do to anyone reading this, which a large part of why I write these things in the first place. Too many times we forgo the opportunity to engage simply because of our aversion to an adverse outcome, I'll be the first to admit that I'm typically like this. I prefer a wide margin of buffer space so that if things to go as planned, the engagement can still be deemed as having achieved some modicum of success. What I loosely term "engagement" in this instance ranges anywhere from a project to a simple conversation.
What drives this apotyphobia? Primarily, I think it's a sense of judgment. One of the worst feelings in the world is to feel condescended or patronized, at least it is for me. Growing up (and I can't say whether or not this is an Asian thing or not) I always had this unconscious sense that being incompetent is worse than being wrong. I want to say that's a line from a movie (Day After Tomorrow maybe?). This nagging certainty that when I do something, I can't look bad doing it, always pervades and thereby, highly limits what I do end up doing. As a guy, this holds true even more when dealing with girls. Maybe it's a societal thing, maybe it's a cultural thing, all I'm sure if is this, at some point in time, or rather at several (more than several) points in time, I am going to screw up, I need to grow up and live with it, ultimately, I need to learn and to grow from it.
While the world isn't really a very friendly place to screw up, the lesson to be learned from this is whether or not I'm okay if someone else screws up. Certainly, there are going to be more critical issues where it's going to be a bigger deal if a mistake is made, but can I live with it, and help the transgressor become a better person from it? My thoughts on this rest largely in the context of church. While we strive for excellence in church, I find that it also should be an environment in which we are comfortable "being human" and thereby falling short. Will it be embarrassing? Most certainly, but as a church, it should be a place where learning experiences can be brought to light from each embarrassment. In order for us to be transparent with one another as we ought to be in the body of Christ, we must trust the intentions of those around us and thereby are willing to just give it our best, regardless of the result. For every success there will be a correlating number of failures, that's how we learn what is going to be successful. Living in a fellowship of Christ doesn't mean getting everything right, but rather, loving one another, even when we get things wrong. A church in which people are afraid to "do the wrong thing" I think needs to take a closer look at the relationships that it has between its members.
I'm certainly not saying I'm okay with screwing up, I hope that people don't walk away with that impression, but rather, the very real possibility of me screwing up doesn't push me to inaction. In some sense you can think of it this way, if nothing happens you're not successful, which is essentially screwing up. It's not a matter of not wanting to get things right all the time, but a matter of being willing to risk getting things wrong. I know I'm apotyphobic, and to some degree, that might be called prudence, but taken too far and it renders me a paralytic. Seize the moment, and if failure ensues, learn from it. Some opportunities only come once.
Friday, January 14, 2011
What's in a word? An exercise in context
Lately, I've been pretty big on the whole concept of contextualization, the reason why we do whatever it is we end up doing. Generally speaking, I find the question of "why?" to be a very important one. While a lot of us will correlate the question perhaps with smart-alecky kids who simply have nothing to do but pester you with "why?" at every single thing you ever say, the inherent reasoning behind our actions is what ultimately compels us to take such action, thus this singular word, why, becomes of the utmost importance, because without it we would do nothing. That's not to say that every answer to the question is a good one, and that we always have a good reason to do what we do, the reason could be a horrible one but good enough to spur us into doing what we do. I write this in the wake of Amy Chua's semi-controversial Wall Street Journal article regarding the superiority of the Chinese parenting methodology (not linking to it because it's in my previous post, so in efforts to shamelessly plug my material, I'm making you go read it). In a brief and concise synopsis of my response to the article my point was simply that successful parenting cannot be measured by what you allow your child to do and the subsequent accomplishments of said child, but rather that a context for what you allow or disallow, why you push to do certain things and discourage him/her from others, is necessary to gauge what makes you a good parent.
Certainly it is true that anything you do well you enjoy it more, and certainly it is also true that it takes work to do anything well. I'll go as far as to say that it's probably true that kids generally don't want to sit down and put in the work it takes to learn to do something well, I'll go even further and say that most people won't. Why is that? Well, simply put, we don't think it's worth it. In ours (and our children's) mindset, there simply isn't a compelling enough reason or benefit to put in the extra work and effort to get good at something. So ultimately, the question boils down to, what good is getting good at something? or succinctly, "why?" While with some things, we sometimes need to be okay with the answer "just because" or in the case of our parents or even spiritual guidance "because I (a parent, leader, or God) say so". However, other times, we really need to sit down and ponder exactly the reasoning behind our action or inaction, and contemplate how "valid" (for lack of a better word) our reasoning is. This holds true for any decision we make, be it for ourselves or for others.
While having purpose behind your actions is something worthwhile (I know, I've set myself up to be asked "why" on every statement), the exercise in context is primarily to help broaden the view to continually keep the end-goal in mind. Maybe the two are the same thing to you, but to me there is a small and subtle difference between the two. I'll explain it this way; just because you have a reason to do something doesn't make it a good reason. Though the same may be said of an end goal, I like to draw a distinction between the two. A reason is what drives the action, an end goal is what you get out of it in the end. I would posit that the latter should be the former. I know it seems like I'm leading you in circles here, but perhaps an example would clarify exactly where I'm trying to get to. When you practice a scale on a piano, you can say you do it for a variety of reasons; to increase manual dexterity, to familiarize yourself with the keyboard, to help better understand where the black keys are, etc... however the ultimate goal is really to become a better pianist. Once we've established that, the question then is "why become a better pianist?" That there is the end goal. Certainly each reason we give is a component of said goal, but it all builds to that one question, which typically will be answered in some form of "just because".
Going back to Amy Chua's article and the subsequent fallout on the internet of responses, mine included, we understand that Ms. Chua does the things she does so that her children can eventually receive (hopefully) a prestigious university education. This is going to sound redundant, but this begs the question, "why go to college?" While most of you might scoff at me at how obvious the answers are, I don't know that the obvious answers are necessarily very good ones. Let's sit down and think about this for a second. For twelve (plus) years of your life, you ultimately are grooming yourself for at least another four years which supposedly define the rest of your existence? Unless you go to grad school. Seriously though, we are groomed from elementary through secondary school to eventually go to an institution, where we pay tens of thousands of dollars for a bunch of administrators telling us we need to know calculus in order to take the class from some guy that will tell us, in a purely academic setting, the conceptual skills necessary to succeed in the "real world". Maybe I'm being a little dramatic with this, but I think it's definitely something consider, because, really? Is this all there is? Ms. Chua spending exorbitant amounts of time and money to get her children to a place where they are given anywhere between 3-6 years to figure out what they want to do for the rest of their lives? College is overwhelming, yes, it's a big transition for most kids, but I would argue that a large part of the reason why college is overwhelming is because we make it so. Not to say that kids shouldn't put in the effort to get into a good school, but if that is the reason for everything they do, then generally, I think they will be ill-equipped to attend any sort of collegiate level institution.
Before I go onto this massive tangent regarding how I think children ought to be raised, my point is this, while we need to have individually measurable and achievable goals (such as, did I get into one of my top 3 college choices?), we also need to continually have the broad overarching picture in mind; to borrow from renown author Chuck Colson: "How Now Shall We Live?" Each of our lives is comprised of a collection of individual moments, and while we live in each moment, our lives as a whole are more than each moment. The context of what we do (in other words why we do what we do) is what defines us. I would urge that we all consider carefully our own contexts.
Certainly it is true that anything you do well you enjoy it more, and certainly it is also true that it takes work to do anything well. I'll go as far as to say that it's probably true that kids generally don't want to sit down and put in the work it takes to learn to do something well, I'll go even further and say that most people won't. Why is that? Well, simply put, we don't think it's worth it. In ours (and our children's) mindset, there simply isn't a compelling enough reason or benefit to put in the extra work and effort to get good at something. So ultimately, the question boils down to, what good is getting good at something? or succinctly, "why?" While with some things, we sometimes need to be okay with the answer "just because" or in the case of our parents or even spiritual guidance "because I (a parent, leader, or God) say so". However, other times, we really need to sit down and ponder exactly the reasoning behind our action or inaction, and contemplate how "valid" (for lack of a better word) our reasoning is. This holds true for any decision we make, be it for ourselves or for others.
While having purpose behind your actions is something worthwhile (I know, I've set myself up to be asked "why" on every statement), the exercise in context is primarily to help broaden the view to continually keep the end-goal in mind. Maybe the two are the same thing to you, but to me there is a small and subtle difference between the two. I'll explain it this way; just because you have a reason to do something doesn't make it a good reason. Though the same may be said of an end goal, I like to draw a distinction between the two. A reason is what drives the action, an end goal is what you get out of it in the end. I would posit that the latter should be the former. I know it seems like I'm leading you in circles here, but perhaps an example would clarify exactly where I'm trying to get to. When you practice a scale on a piano, you can say you do it for a variety of reasons; to increase manual dexterity, to familiarize yourself with the keyboard, to help better understand where the black keys are, etc... however the ultimate goal is really to become a better pianist. Once we've established that, the question then is "why become a better pianist?" That there is the end goal. Certainly each reason we give is a component of said goal, but it all builds to that one question, which typically will be answered in some form of "just because".
Going back to Amy Chua's article and the subsequent fallout on the internet of responses, mine included, we understand that Ms. Chua does the things she does so that her children can eventually receive (hopefully) a prestigious university education. This is going to sound redundant, but this begs the question, "why go to college?" While most of you might scoff at me at how obvious the answers are, I don't know that the obvious answers are necessarily very good ones. Let's sit down and think about this for a second. For twelve (plus) years of your life, you ultimately are grooming yourself for at least another four years which supposedly define the rest of your existence? Unless you go to grad school. Seriously though, we are groomed from elementary through secondary school to eventually go to an institution, where we pay tens of thousands of dollars for a bunch of administrators telling us we need to know calculus in order to take the class from some guy that will tell us, in a purely academic setting, the conceptual skills necessary to succeed in the "real world". Maybe I'm being a little dramatic with this, but I think it's definitely something consider, because, really? Is this all there is? Ms. Chua spending exorbitant amounts of time and money to get her children to a place where they are given anywhere between 3-6 years to figure out what they want to do for the rest of their lives? College is overwhelming, yes, it's a big transition for most kids, but I would argue that a large part of the reason why college is overwhelming is because we make it so. Not to say that kids shouldn't put in the effort to get into a good school, but if that is the reason for everything they do, then generally, I think they will be ill-equipped to attend any sort of collegiate level institution.
Before I go onto this massive tangent regarding how I think children ought to be raised, my point is this, while we need to have individually measurable and achievable goals (such as, did I get into one of my top 3 college choices?), we also need to continually have the broad overarching picture in mind; to borrow from renown author Chuck Colson: "How Now Shall We Live?" Each of our lives is comprised of a collection of individual moments, and while we live in each moment, our lives as a whole are more than each moment. The context of what we do (in other words why we do what we do) is what defines us. I would urge that we all consider carefully our own contexts.
Tuesday, January 11, 2011
Measured Success
Recently, among my circle of friends and family, I found this little article circulating. Today, a friend of mine (one who had linked to the article in her GChat status), linked to this response. I suppose this is my take on it, though I don't know that I can fully put myself in that situation, as I can never be a Chinese mother, though I do have one myself. I'm not going to go on and say who is right and who isn't, not going to go into the psychology of child-rearing, and I'm not going to tell anyone how to raise his/her children. I'm not a parent myself, and perhaps I didn't have the most typical of Chinese parents, or at least according to Amy Chua, I didn't. However, I just find it very interesting the scope of the article and all that.
I just noted that in the headline of the article it reads:
I have a job (in this economy), I feel I'm living a well adjusted life, full of loving friends and family, and I'm happy with where I am, I'm content. Now, am I successful? Hard to say. It sort of begs the question: what is success? Is it based on what I have? If that's the case, then I'd say I'm moderately successful. I mean, I have nice apartment, a car, a job, a computer, some decent pieces of musical equipment, a my fair share of toys and gadgets, a bachelor's and a master's, then again, I also have debt from school. On that same note, there are a lot of things I don't have, a girlfriend, a house, lots of money, etc... Still, then, the question of success eludes me. I can only suggest that I am not unsuccessful. This inclines me towards the notion that success then, is a subjective and relative term. To me, success is measured by an end goal, therefore, the phrase "successful person" doesn't really hold much water. Think about it, realistically, what is the end goal of a person? I can say an experiment was either a success or failure by its results. I can say that a basketball coach is successful or not by how his/her team plays, by the team's record, are they winning more games? Are the players getting better? Yet what is that measure in a person? Wealth? Acclaim? Character? I posit, that at best, we can simply point out those that are "not unsuccessful". While the question is the same, the nature of what we measure is different with happiness.
I'm not here to say that it's bad to have/be a math whiz or musical prodigy, but I think everything needs to be put in an appropriate context, and ultimately that is the context of life. Chinese parents will spend tens of thousands of dollars (I'm not kidding) and hours for the musical and academic enrichment of their children, and for what purpose? As an aficionado of music, I'd be the first to tell you that I think children should all be given the opportunity to appreciate and make music, yet Ms. Hsu, in her response brings up the very legitimate point that Chinese (Asian) parents will often be displeased if music were to inspire their children to become a professional musician (or, as an ongoing joke, any profession not inclusive of doctors, lawyers, or engineers). Contextually then, what is the purpose of learning a musical instrument? Generally in the case of Chinese children, piano and/or violin. While perhaps that is asking a lot of a child, I don't know that I would condone asking one to do something he/she cannot answer why he/she is doing it (even if the answer is as simple as, "I like it"). One thing I've noted about Chinese culture, is that it's all about appearances, but to me, it frankly is a horrible reason to do something because every other Asian child is doing it or so that you can brag to your friends about your child. I'm sorry, but being able to play Rachmaninoff's Variations on Paganini at age 8 is hardly indicative to me of "good parenting", and yes, when you tell your friend how much your son/daughter studies/practices you're really saying, "Look at how well I discipline my children." While I don't doubt that every single Chinese parent has a picture of who/what he/she would want his/her child to become, there remains an issue; is the child on board? My personal experience, as well as my observations fellow 2nd generation Chinese children around me, has shown that generally, Chinese parenting is very short sighted. Ms. Hsu points out a lack of drive in Chinese children growing up, and I attribute that to above-mentioned short-sightedness. It's hard to get anyone really motivated about something if the driving reason behind doing it is being told by someone else to do it. You ask the question "Why?" enough times and you'll quickly realize that a lot of things these kids do simply because their parents have programmed them to be like that. Why get good grades? To go to a good college. Why go to a good college? To get a good job. Why get a good job? To make money to support a family. While none of these things are undesirable, I certainly don't see those as the purpose of existence.
Ms. Chua is to be commended for her perseverance in pushing her children to achieve, but again, we have to ask the question "to what end?" Certainly I believe in a degree of regimen growing up teaches us responsibility, but to essentially obliterate any "frivolous" childhood activity? Perhaps, I'll be accused of becoming "too American" but that hardly seems healthy. The Atkins diet is good, but that doesn't mean that's all you do for the rest of your life. We are to enjoy in the people, the places, and the things that God has placed around us, so living a life where what you "like" is irrelevant and "having a good time" is wasteful hardly seems like something God would want for us. In the case of music, the children are often asked to "grow out of" whatever they spent all that time, sweat, and dollars getting this stuff hammered into them. Isn't that frivolous? Certainly there is something other than music that can teach discipline. So, that begs the question, why have them learn music in the first place? The grand scheme of things, ultimately, I believe is for your children to grow up into productive, well-adjusted adults. How do painful hours of sitting in front of a piano either practicing, performing, or in lessons help? I'm not ungrateful my mom had me learn piano, and sometimes I do wish she pushed me harder, on that same note though, it's because in retrospect, there are a lot of things I would enjoy doing now had I been a better pianist as a child, in other words, I'm still playing piano. My father once told me after I graduated, "Now you can play well enough to play for praise in church, to me, that means the piano lessons were worth it." Context. Not that playing for church was the goal of my piano lessons, but, there needs to be something beyond that last recital if your child isn't going to become the next Lang Lang, even if it is the simple appreciation of music. I'm not accusing Ms. Chua of ruining her children's childhoods, no, it sounds like her husband does take them out to fun stuff, movies, baseball games, etc... Nonetheless, this no-nonsense style of raising her children is exactly that, a style, there's no basis for her to posit that hers is better than others, to do so is simply arrogance.
I suppose what makes this article somewhat intriguing, is this concept of superiority, that one is better than the other. Certainly, Ms. Chua brings up very good points in not allowing her children to give up, and I applaud her for her tenacity and her dedication, however, under what presumed authority can she say that what she is doing is "better" than the next parent who is perhaps by her standards more "lenient" on his/her child? I would posit the following broad generality based on the sort of broad sweeping generality that Ms. Chua has illustrated in her article: while Chinese parents may know (or at least think they know) what is best for their children, they don't know their children all that well. In her article, Ms. Chua all but writes off the concept of self-esteem, and sure, she's entitled to her opinions and her thoughts, and thus, she's very hard on her children when it comes to results. I posit this though, and perhaps Ms. Chua is different, but most Chinese parents aren't aware of how hard their children are on themselves. Going back to the music example, since that is one of the more understandable examples, "you played it wrong" is probably the most useless piece of feedback anyone can give/get. While the parent has spent the money sending the child to music lessons, the child is the one who has spent the time and effort studying the music, so therefore, the child probably knows more about music, or at the very least more about whatever piece he/she is practicing than the parent does, and generally will know if/when it is played incorrectly. It's kind of like telling someone who's parking he/she is close to the curb AFTER the car has run up on the sidewalk. While it's nice of Ms. Chua to think that there are no natural limitations in regards to what her children can do (at least musically and academically), can she affirm that the way she does things works for both of her children exactly the same way? No. While the intention may be good, a lot of times the comparison of one child to another comes across to the "lesser" child as simply, "Why are you so dumb?" or "What's wrong with you?" rather than "You can do it too". Calling your child "garbage" can be a learning implement, but as with all implements it must be properly used to be effective.
The more I think about how I want to proceed with this, the more I realize how this can exponentially bubble into any number of long-debated topics, from positive versus negative reinforcement to nature versus nurture. Now, I'm no psychologist, so I'm not going to get into all of this, so I suppose I've touched upon everything that really kind of irked me about this article. Maybe a Chinese kid can score higher on a math test or play some remarkably difficult piece at a younger age, but is that really all there is to it? If it is, then life is dumb. I'm all for giving children opportunities, but they have lives too, at some point in time, they need to live it.
I just noted that in the headline of the article it reads:
And then the first line of the article suddenly jumps into:
Can a regimen of no playdates, no TV, no computer games and hours of music practice create happy kids?
A lot of people wonder how Chinese parents raise such stereotypically successful kids. They wonder what these parents do to produce so many math whizzes and music prodigies, what it's like inside the family, and whether they could do it too.Hm... I don't know, there seems to be something of a dichotomy here. At least to me there is. What is this dichotomy? First, happiness and success. Are they one and the same? The second, math whizzes, music prodigies and success. Same question. Okay, so maybe dichotomy is a strong word, but I do find the immediate juxtaposition that Ms. Chua strings together within her article somewhat... well... hard to swallow. Of course, who am I to say anything? Relatively speaking, I'm hardly a typical "Chinese success story". I didn't get straight As in school, I didn't go to an Ivy League university for undergraduate, I didn't go to a "West Coast Ivy" like Stanford or Cal Tech, I didn't even go to a top 5 state university in the nation. Sure I played piano when I was younger, classically, my teacher lamented at my practice habits and called me her student with the most "unrealized potential", which essentially is an offhanded way of saying I could've been good if I tried or worked harder, so no, I never played in Carnegie Hall, or performed with some orchestra on tour. Biggest thing I've done is play in a couple of local competition recitals, a couple of local piano teacher showcase recitals, a master class, and a personal recital when I graduated from high school, oh, and I got paid once to play for a Unitarian church service. Now, I have a job, maybe I'll stay at it, maybe I won't. For one, I'm not a doctor, nor a lawyer, nor an engineer. By my schooling, I'm supposed to be an accountant (which I'm not right now vocationally), and I'm not even too sure I want to be that either. Does this mean I have failed to succeed? In other words, does this mean I'm a failure?
I have a job (in this economy), I feel I'm living a well adjusted life, full of loving friends and family, and I'm happy with where I am, I'm content. Now, am I successful? Hard to say. It sort of begs the question: what is success? Is it based on what I have? If that's the case, then I'd say I'm moderately successful. I mean, I have nice apartment, a car, a job, a computer, some decent pieces of musical equipment, a my fair share of toys and gadgets, a bachelor's and a master's, then again, I also have debt from school. On that same note, there are a lot of things I don't have, a girlfriend, a house, lots of money, etc... Still, then, the question of success eludes me. I can only suggest that I am not unsuccessful. This inclines me towards the notion that success then, is a subjective and relative term. To me, success is measured by an end goal, therefore, the phrase "successful person" doesn't really hold much water. Think about it, realistically, what is the end goal of a person? I can say an experiment was either a success or failure by its results. I can say that a basketball coach is successful or not by how his/her team plays, by the team's record, are they winning more games? Are the players getting better? Yet what is that measure in a person? Wealth? Acclaim? Character? I posit, that at best, we can simply point out those that are "not unsuccessful". While the question is the same, the nature of what we measure is different with happiness.
I'm not here to say that it's bad to have/be a math whiz or musical prodigy, but I think everything needs to be put in an appropriate context, and ultimately that is the context of life. Chinese parents will spend tens of thousands of dollars (I'm not kidding) and hours for the musical and academic enrichment of their children, and for what purpose? As an aficionado of music, I'd be the first to tell you that I think children should all be given the opportunity to appreciate and make music, yet Ms. Hsu, in her response brings up the very legitimate point that Chinese (Asian) parents will often be displeased if music were to inspire their children to become a professional musician (or, as an ongoing joke, any profession not inclusive of doctors, lawyers, or engineers). Contextually then, what is the purpose of learning a musical instrument? Generally in the case of Chinese children, piano and/or violin. While perhaps that is asking a lot of a child, I don't know that I would condone asking one to do something he/she cannot answer why he/she is doing it (even if the answer is as simple as, "I like it"). One thing I've noted about Chinese culture, is that it's all about appearances, but to me, it frankly is a horrible reason to do something because every other Asian child is doing it or so that you can brag to your friends about your child. I'm sorry, but being able to play Rachmaninoff's Variations on Paganini at age 8 is hardly indicative to me of "good parenting", and yes, when you tell your friend how much your son/daughter studies/practices you're really saying, "Look at how well I discipline my children." While I don't doubt that every single Chinese parent has a picture of who/what he/she would want his/her child to become, there remains an issue; is the child on board? My personal experience, as well as my observations fellow 2nd generation Chinese children around me, has shown that generally, Chinese parenting is very short sighted. Ms. Hsu points out a lack of drive in Chinese children growing up, and I attribute that to above-mentioned short-sightedness. It's hard to get anyone really motivated about something if the driving reason behind doing it is being told by someone else to do it. You ask the question "Why?" enough times and you'll quickly realize that a lot of things these kids do simply because their parents have programmed them to be like that. Why get good grades? To go to a good college. Why go to a good college? To get a good job. Why get a good job? To make money to support a family. While none of these things are undesirable, I certainly don't see those as the purpose of existence.
Ms. Chua is to be commended for her perseverance in pushing her children to achieve, but again, we have to ask the question "to what end?" Certainly I believe in a degree of regimen growing up teaches us responsibility, but to essentially obliterate any "frivolous" childhood activity? Perhaps, I'll be accused of becoming "too American" but that hardly seems healthy. The Atkins diet is good, but that doesn't mean that's all you do for the rest of your life. We are to enjoy in the people, the places, and the things that God has placed around us, so living a life where what you "like" is irrelevant and "having a good time" is wasteful hardly seems like something God would want for us. In the case of music, the children are often asked to "grow out of" whatever they spent all that time, sweat, and dollars getting this stuff hammered into them. Isn't that frivolous? Certainly there is something other than music that can teach discipline. So, that begs the question, why have them learn music in the first place? The grand scheme of things, ultimately, I believe is for your children to grow up into productive, well-adjusted adults. How do painful hours of sitting in front of a piano either practicing, performing, or in lessons help? I'm not ungrateful my mom had me learn piano, and sometimes I do wish she pushed me harder, on that same note though, it's because in retrospect, there are a lot of things I would enjoy doing now had I been a better pianist as a child, in other words, I'm still playing piano. My father once told me after I graduated, "Now you can play well enough to play for praise in church, to me, that means the piano lessons were worth it." Context. Not that playing for church was the goal of my piano lessons, but, there needs to be something beyond that last recital if your child isn't going to become the next Lang Lang, even if it is the simple appreciation of music. I'm not accusing Ms. Chua of ruining her children's childhoods, no, it sounds like her husband does take them out to fun stuff, movies, baseball games, etc... Nonetheless, this no-nonsense style of raising her children is exactly that, a style, there's no basis for her to posit that hers is better than others, to do so is simply arrogance.
I suppose what makes this article somewhat intriguing, is this concept of superiority, that one is better than the other. Certainly, Ms. Chua brings up very good points in not allowing her children to give up, and I applaud her for her tenacity and her dedication, however, under what presumed authority can she say that what she is doing is "better" than the next parent who is perhaps by her standards more "lenient" on his/her child? I would posit the following broad generality based on the sort of broad sweeping generality that Ms. Chua has illustrated in her article: while Chinese parents may know (or at least think they know) what is best for their children, they don't know their children all that well. In her article, Ms. Chua all but writes off the concept of self-esteem, and sure, she's entitled to her opinions and her thoughts, and thus, she's very hard on her children when it comes to results. I posit this though, and perhaps Ms. Chua is different, but most Chinese parents aren't aware of how hard their children are on themselves. Going back to the music example, since that is one of the more understandable examples, "you played it wrong" is probably the most useless piece of feedback anyone can give/get. While the parent has spent the money sending the child to music lessons, the child is the one who has spent the time and effort studying the music, so therefore, the child probably knows more about music, or at the very least more about whatever piece he/she is practicing than the parent does, and generally will know if/when it is played incorrectly. It's kind of like telling someone who's parking he/she is close to the curb AFTER the car has run up on the sidewalk. While it's nice of Ms. Chua to think that there are no natural limitations in regards to what her children can do (at least musically and academically), can she affirm that the way she does things works for both of her children exactly the same way? No. While the intention may be good, a lot of times the comparison of one child to another comes across to the "lesser" child as simply, "Why are you so dumb?" or "What's wrong with you?" rather than "You can do it too". Calling your child "garbage" can be a learning implement, but as with all implements it must be properly used to be effective.
The more I think about how I want to proceed with this, the more I realize how this can exponentially bubble into any number of long-debated topics, from positive versus negative reinforcement to nature versus nurture. Now, I'm no psychologist, so I'm not going to get into all of this, so I suppose I've touched upon everything that really kind of irked me about this article. Maybe a Chinese kid can score higher on a math test or play some remarkably difficult piece at a younger age, but is that really all there is to it? If it is, then life is dumb. I'm all for giving children opportunities, but they have lives too, at some point in time, they need to live it.
Tuesday, December 14, 2010
On a lighter note...
I kind of posted about this earlier, but now with the advent of the new hit musical Rock of Ages, it's gotten me thinking a little more. While the concept of shoving as many great radio hits into some semblance of a storyline would be cool, wouldn't it be that much more hilarious if it were entirely out of context? I think that's part of what made Mamma Mia a great hit, well sort of. Not that I don't want to see Rock of Ages, I totally do, but the story is too contrived to fit these songs in, of course, that's probably the easiest way to do it, but what if, what if we took something completely unrelated and then throw in stuff that marginally works? I'm not claiming this would be an immediate hit, but it definitely would make things interesting, and I think hilarity would ensue. For example, I love Phantom of the Opera, and I'm sure now Andrew Lloyd Webber would be turning in his grave to see me do this to his musical, but you feasibly could replace the score with songs by The Police, and it would still kind of work. I mean, I can totally see the Phantom singing Every Move You Make rather than Music of the Night or something. Someone is now going to throw something at me, so I'll stop.
Wednesday, November 10, 2010
If we'd only try...
I think this post is actually somewhat a continuation of my previous post, however disconnected my ideas conceptions were. I heard recently that, "there are no such things as soul mates". It's a very interesting statement, regardless of whether or not I agree or disagree. Of course, this ultimately boils down to what we define as a "soul mate". Intuitively, I'm inclined to think of a soul mate as someone whom God has prepared for someone else, and perhaps this is where my definition deviates from issuers of such statements. However, let's not get into that, I'm not here to discuss God's providence and marriage. Rather, let's consider a lot of times what society today construes as being a "soul mate". From my understanding (which I concede is rather limited), modern culture depicts soul mates as two people who just kind of "click". They'll always get along, they'll always be happy together, etc... I believe this view is often perpetuated by the constant "love-at-first-sight" kind of romances that happen in all sorts of fictional works; books, movies, television programming, etc...
Now, I want to move to a point where we step away from all this "romance" stuff, because this concept I think applies to all relationships in general. It's natural that we connect with some people more naturally than others. When we converse with one another, we generally need something to talk about. Hence why people who have the same interest generally can and will group together, they have something to talk about. Already there is the bond of a shared passion there. However, I hope that everyone would agree with me that friendship should be more than the things we have in common. Being human, there will ALWAYS be times when we are in disagreement with others, where my interests conflict with someone else's (my friend's). This could be a somewhat alien concept (while I hope it isn't, I wouldn't be surprised if it was), friendships are relationships in spite of the differences that separate us. Ultimately, I think the closeness of a relationship is measured by the amount of time spent with the other person. Time spent with each other may or may not be physical time, it could be done over the phone, Skype, mail, etc... depending on each person. Naturally, physical proximity is that much more poignant than more "long-distance" means of communication, but still, it is time spent with the other person.
We as a people are very good at compartmentalizing things. Each aspect of life goes into its own little box and never shall items be mixed. However, we as people are individuals, not stacks of boxes. I know for myself, I have a little hobby box here, and I hope to develop relationships with people in that box, but if I don't see them outside of the context of that hobby, how can I really get to know them? How can they get to know me? Perpetually, I'd probably end up as "that guy that's pretty fun to play volleyball with". It takes continual work and effort to get to know someone, but oftentimes we kind of just "expect" it to happen. We may not believe in "soul mates" but it's definitive that we connect with some people better than others. Even then, there isn't anyone out there that won't take work to get to know, we don't make best friends every other day. Part of what makes that friendship special is the time that has been invested into it. What am I putting in?
Now, I want to move to a point where we step away from all this "romance" stuff, because this concept I think applies to all relationships in general. It's natural that we connect with some people more naturally than others. When we converse with one another, we generally need something to talk about. Hence why people who have the same interest generally can and will group together, they have something to talk about. Already there is the bond of a shared passion there. However, I hope that everyone would agree with me that friendship should be more than the things we have in common. Being human, there will ALWAYS be times when we are in disagreement with others, where my interests conflict with someone else's (my friend's). This could be a somewhat alien concept (while I hope it isn't, I wouldn't be surprised if it was), friendships are relationships in spite of the differences that separate us. Ultimately, I think the closeness of a relationship is measured by the amount of time spent with the other person. Time spent with each other may or may not be physical time, it could be done over the phone, Skype, mail, etc... depending on each person. Naturally, physical proximity is that much more poignant than more "long-distance" means of communication, but still, it is time spent with the other person.
We as a people are very good at compartmentalizing things. Each aspect of life goes into its own little box and never shall items be mixed. However, we as people are individuals, not stacks of boxes. I know for myself, I have a little hobby box here, and I hope to develop relationships with people in that box, but if I don't see them outside of the context of that hobby, how can I really get to know them? How can they get to know me? Perpetually, I'd probably end up as "that guy that's pretty fun to play volleyball with". It takes continual work and effort to get to know someone, but oftentimes we kind of just "expect" it to happen. We may not believe in "soul mates" but it's definitive that we connect with some people better than others. Even then, there isn't anyone out there that won't take work to get to know, we don't make best friends every other day. Part of what makes that friendship special is the time that has been invested into it. What am I putting in?
Tuesday, September 7, 2010
Do we even care anymore?
Sorry if my recent posts have been somewhat brooding as of late, that just tends to be my state of mind. Perhaps I should take the, "If you have nothing positive to say then don't say anything" approach but then, I'd be starving all 2 readers of this blog of any legitimate content. I'm not really here to provide any scathing commentary on the state of society and modern culture, but I feel like it's really gotten to a point where the status quo has degenerated into some form of polite apathy. Have you ever noticed that? I suppose I'm personally as much to blame as anyone, I do it a lot too, and as much as I want to blame my natural inclination towards introversion, I don't find it to be much of an excuse.
More and more I find that we try to occupy ourselves with various hobbies, past-times, etc... We involve ourselves with various clubs and associations, getting on the latest trends of the hottest hobbies, researching the best gear and the most effective techniques to do whatever it is we suddenly love doing better. We find the hottest locations and where everyone goes locally to do whatever it is you do. Not to say that this is a bad thing, it's not. Perhaps it's been taken a little too far though? Maybe I'm just being cynical and jaded, but has suddenly the thing we're doing suddenly become more important who we do it with? Again, I'm not trying to throw out some scathing commentary on our current cultural condition, but rather just a simple observation how things seem to me.
Maybe I'm just strange, but have you ever wanted to have just a deeper conversation? As sappy as they are, why do you think Hollywood keeps making these "soul mate" chick flicks? Why are we so stirred by men who understand each other so as to be as brothers? (I hope that this analogy still rings true today, despite the general degradation of familial bonds within recent times). When I think about it though, 80% of my conversations are "small talk" or "shop talk". "How are you doing?" has become a cliched kind of greeting where the obligatory answer is the synonym of a shrug or if you're a little more optimistic "Pretty good." Not to say that I want to go discussing deep philosophy with the next random stranger I meet or that every other conversation has to be about something "deep", but there certainly it is a lonely existence where we cannot share in life with others. While much of life is shared doing stuff together, lives are also matters of the heart; what is weighing upon our hearts, what is inspiring us, etc... It's sad that our interest is only piqued when we discuss things we like to do rather than how the person we're talking to actually is. I don't know that it's that we're so cold and apathetic that we don't care or want to care, but rather, perhaps we're just too caught up in ourselves. Let's open our eyes up a little.
More and more I find that we try to occupy ourselves with various hobbies, past-times, etc... We involve ourselves with various clubs and associations, getting on the latest trends of the hottest hobbies, researching the best gear and the most effective techniques to do whatever it is we suddenly love doing better. We find the hottest locations and where everyone goes locally to do whatever it is you do. Not to say that this is a bad thing, it's not. Perhaps it's been taken a little too far though? Maybe I'm just being cynical and jaded, but has suddenly the thing we're doing suddenly become more important who we do it with? Again, I'm not trying to throw out some scathing commentary on our current cultural condition, but rather just a simple observation how things seem to me.
Maybe I'm just strange, but have you ever wanted to have just a deeper conversation? As sappy as they are, why do you think Hollywood keeps making these "soul mate" chick flicks? Why are we so stirred by men who understand each other so as to be as brothers? (I hope that this analogy still rings true today, despite the general degradation of familial bonds within recent times). When I think about it though, 80% of my conversations are "small talk" or "shop talk". "How are you doing?" has become a cliched kind of greeting where the obligatory answer is the synonym of a shrug or if you're a little more optimistic "Pretty good." Not to say that I want to go discussing deep philosophy with the next random stranger I meet or that every other conversation has to be about something "deep", but there certainly it is a lonely existence where we cannot share in life with others. While much of life is shared doing stuff together, lives are also matters of the heart; what is weighing upon our hearts, what is inspiring us, etc... It's sad that our interest is only piqued when we discuss things we like to do rather than how the person we're talking to actually is. I don't know that it's that we're so cold and apathetic that we don't care or want to care, but rather, perhaps we're just too caught up in ourselves. Let's open our eyes up a little.
Monday, August 23, 2010
Growing up isn't easy
I'm not dead, just, lazy? Anyways, today's random thought, is about growing up. I remember as a child, I looked up to adults and think, "Man, they got it all figured out." Today, I am among that population of "adults", even though I still think to myself, "Man, they got it all figured out." Implicitly saying, I don't have it figured out, which I don't. I suppose part of me is caught up in the consumerist attitude of everything being just kind of given to me when I pass "Go" enough times and can pay up. Perhaps I'm just cynical, but the great epiphany of life, at least for myself, is that there isn't a great epiphany of life. Things don't just fall into place and everything makes sense and works out. Sometimes it providentially does, but it really is an act of God.
In the end I think it's all about how the little things add together to make the bigger picture. Nonetheless, I'm an adult, I've got it worked out right? Not. The word "adult" really is intimidating, and I'm not entirely comfortable labeling myself with it, though technically I'm already years past legally qualifying for the honor. Will it make sense with more time? Maybe, but not time alone. Maybe I just haven't had my epiphany yet, but still, life goes on. I can't just stop because my personal life hasn't been sorted out, I have to do it on the fly. How do I do that? Well, one thing I realize more as I grow older is the enormity of the extent of things I can't do. More and more, I realize that while I'm bumbling about hoping to serndipidously stumble upon the right answer, there's someone I know that's got it all figured out already, I just have to ask. So, I just need to trust Him (the guy with the right answers) and trust His answers, and live accordingly. Things will work out in the end. He's got it figured out.
In the end I think it's all about how the little things add together to make the bigger picture. Nonetheless, I'm an adult, I've got it worked out right? Not. The word "adult" really is intimidating, and I'm not entirely comfortable labeling myself with it, though technically I'm already years past legally qualifying for the honor. Will it make sense with more time? Maybe, but not time alone. Maybe I just haven't had my epiphany yet, but still, life goes on. I can't just stop because my personal life hasn't been sorted out, I have to do it on the fly. How do I do that? Well, one thing I realize more as I grow older is the enormity of the extent of things I can't do. More and more, I realize that while I'm bumbling about hoping to serndipidously stumble upon the right answer, there's someone I know that's got it all figured out already, I just have to ask. So, I just need to trust Him (the guy with the right answers) and trust His answers, and live accordingly. Things will work out in the end. He's got it figured out.
Tuesday, May 18, 2010
Not enough...
I find it intriguing that we often complain we don't have enough of things. Maybe it's a sign of the modern era of discontentment. I mean, we always say, "Grass is always greener on the other side." Though I'm not here to really talk about how we are a very instant-gratification generation, how we have to have things now. I'm in a sort of contemplative mood, I suppose, so now I'm going to do some contemplative ranting. So here goes... I don't believe the statement, "I don't have enough time..." This is something that's a little difficult for me to articulate, but it's something that I frankly don't believe is really the case a lot of times when people say it. How should I put this?
Time, I think is like money. The primary difference is that everyone has a fixed amount whereas our earning potential has some flexibility. There are things we need to spend our money on; food, clothing, rent, bills, etc... What money we have remaining we can spend on the remaining things that we want or in some cases to improve on the niceties of such things we spend our money on. Likewise, we have things we ought to spend our time on; work (be it vocation or school), family, sleep (seriously, we do), etc... We were given 24 hours in a day for a reason, I'm sure that it's not impossible to get by with just that amount, otherwise we'd have more. I think I'm sort of at a loss as to where exactly I was going with this...
It's basically along these lines, we spend on what we find to be important. Generally, we spend in sequence of descending importance, the things that are important get first priority, as our resources are limited, it's uncertain as to when we're going to run out at any given point in time, thus it's only natural that we want to get the most important things out of the way first. So I guess the first point would be to really take time to recognize what you're spending (time and money) on. Maybe I'm just overly-sensitive, but this I feel becomes extraordinarily important especially when it comes to relating with other people. I suppose I wouldn't really think of things this way if I didn't first come up with this perspective on spending, so I only really have myself to blame.
In terms of relationships, we can spend both money and time as well. Generally, spending a ton of money I don't think works very well. Thus, I think more indicative of how seriously a person takes a relationship is the time spent "invested" into the relationship. Naturally, there are things we absolutely have to spend our time on, but I think too often we blur the lines between need and want. Simply put, since we only have 24 hours to the day, at some point in time, something is going to have to give. Oftentimes people forgo meals or sleep in order to do the things they find to be important. What I'm ultimately saying is that we MAKE time for what's important. Isn't that how we do things already? We allocate a certain degree of relative importance to our tasks on hand and then accordingly allocate the time we have available appropriately. While we may not find something as mundane as meeting and catching up with a friend to be "unimportant" it certainly would fall low on a scale of relative importance. Thus the question falls back to one of perspective. We measure not only tasks but also hobbies and even relationships and determine what things are worth spending on.
I suppose the direction I'm going here is a call to introspection, figuring out what really is important. We certainly say a lot of things but is it true? Think about it this way, in the event of a schedule conflict, what takes precedence? While the whole process may be very similar to asking yourself in a schedule conflict, which you would rather do, the difference is there. What takes precedence really is a mirror of what you hold to be important. As calloused as it may sound, if, in the event of a schedule conflict, I found that going to open gym volleyball was more important than meeting my friend for dinner, then the reality of the situation is that I find volleyball to be more important than that dinner date. This isn't to say that I can't schedule things around when I play volleyball (dinner included), but when push comes to shove something has to give. When I cannot accommodate a friend who really wants to meet but can only do so on a specific date, then in some sense, I have put whatever it is I'm doing (volleyball, work, school, other friends, etc...) in front of that friend in terms of importance. We make time for what's important, that's how things are. I understand that we all weigh the varying factors of life differently, some of us think work is more important, some of us friends, some of us school, etc... My thing is this, just take an inventory now and figure out what's important and if that's what you want to be important. When I don't have "enough time" for something, I think it ultimately means this: it's not important enough.
It's basically along these lines, we spend on what we find to be important. Generally, we spend in sequence of descending importance, the things that are important get first priority, as our resources are limited, it's uncertain as to when we're going to run out at any given point in time, thus it's only natural that we want to get the most important things out of the way first. So I guess the first point would be to really take time to recognize what you're spending (time and money) on. Maybe I'm just overly-sensitive, but this I feel becomes extraordinarily important especially when it comes to relating with other people. I suppose I wouldn't really think of things this way if I didn't first come up with this perspective on spending, so I only really have myself to blame.
In terms of relationships, we can spend both money and time as well. Generally, spending a ton of money I don't think works very well. Thus, I think more indicative of how seriously a person takes a relationship is the time spent "invested" into the relationship. Naturally, there are things we absolutely have to spend our time on, but I think too often we blur the lines between need and want. Simply put, since we only have 24 hours to the day, at some point in time, something is going to have to give. Oftentimes people forgo meals or sleep in order to do the things they find to be important. What I'm ultimately saying is that we MAKE time for what's important. Isn't that how we do things already? We allocate a certain degree of relative importance to our tasks on hand and then accordingly allocate the time we have available appropriately. While we may not find something as mundane as meeting and catching up with a friend to be "unimportant" it certainly would fall low on a scale of relative importance. Thus the question falls back to one of perspective. We measure not only tasks but also hobbies and even relationships and determine what things are worth spending on.
I suppose the direction I'm going here is a call to introspection, figuring out what really is important. We certainly say a lot of things but is it true? Think about it this way, in the event of a schedule conflict, what takes precedence? While the whole process may be very similar to asking yourself in a schedule conflict, which you would rather do, the difference is there. What takes precedence really is a mirror of what you hold to be important. As calloused as it may sound, if, in the event of a schedule conflict, I found that going to open gym volleyball was more important than meeting my friend for dinner, then the reality of the situation is that I find volleyball to be more important than that dinner date. This isn't to say that I can't schedule things around when I play volleyball (dinner included), but when push comes to shove something has to give. When I cannot accommodate a friend who really wants to meet but can only do so on a specific date, then in some sense, I have put whatever it is I'm doing (volleyball, work, school, other friends, etc...) in front of that friend in terms of importance. We make time for what's important, that's how things are. I understand that we all weigh the varying factors of life differently, some of us think work is more important, some of us friends, some of us school, etc... My thing is this, just take an inventory now and figure out what's important and if that's what you want to be important. When I don't have "enough time" for something, I think it ultimately means this: it's not important enough.
Sunday, February 21, 2010
The Remarkable Jading Effect of Time
Hm... Was the title a little too cynical? I dunno, it's just something I've been thinking about. It's kind of sad that I haven't realized it until now, but have you noticed that things get less interesting as time passes? I know I've heard it before, the more I do things the more commonplace they become and they lose their initial appeal, maybe that's it. I used to always want to go to McDonald's and my mom would say how if I had too much McDonald's I'd get sick of it. I didn't really believe her of course, but then, I didn't have McDonald's everyday either. Nonetheless, it's interesting how remarkably unappealing the mundane and routine become once they become mundane and routine. It's weird.
This is something that I find happening in life, and more specifically through my personal walk of faith. It's rather ironic, but what was once construed as spiritual fervor is now viewed with a rather cynical perspective. Everything that I once was passionate about has become cliched, and I wish it weren't so. A lot of times I go back to those cliched attitudes and sayings, and I sometimes cringe at how cliched it is, but also, I remember, how when it wasn't so. It's a difficult battle, and one that I think we need to be aware of. Time jades, we should realize that. I don't know if it's a by-product of the cynicism in our society or if it's the natural degeneration of man, but it happens. There's an opening line to a song that I've been listening to lately, and it goes like thus, "Can I look past the cliches?" Well, can I?
I suppose this has been a little on the depressing side, so I suppose I'll try to put a more positive perspective on this. I believe that in understanding this it's a calling to bring us back to the simplicity of children, where there are no cliches. Just because it's cliched doesn't make it wrong. Just overused, but we always have to have that fresh perspective, that kid constantly craving the simple things. I've noticed most of it comes back to a matter of perspective. As life progresses the wonder comes out of things little by little, but I believe with the proper perspective, things can be better.
Tuesday, August 4, 2009
A.D.
If I were to just leave the title at that, you'd think I'd be doing some kind of post on the naming convention of the years. Something about anno domini Latin for "In the year of our Lord". However, in this case, I mean AD to stand for something else, it has nothing to do with the Western calendar, what I wish to discuss today is this one concept summed up in two English words; after death. I suppose I could be fancy and have done PM and used like post mortem or something but I'm sure you get the general idea, and I'm tired of trying to be witty and creative.
So let's give a little context, where did I come up with the motivation to write on such a (seemingly) morbid subject? Well, a few of the youth kids I know from my church went to a conference called Worldview Academy, and during street evangelism sessions, one of the common lead-in questions used was this: "Where do you go after you die?". It's a question people don't often give much thought to, at least not when they're younger, yet it is a question of utmost importance in life. Perhaps I could say it's a matter of perspective, how? Well, in the sense that knowing the choices of where you end up is a good motivator of what you do now and how you go about doing it. An example of such would be someone studying hard now because he/she wishes to attend a better college/university in the future. It is that goal of the university, say an Ivy League versus a local community college, that pushes our student here to study. If perhaps that example doesn't ring home, it is also the idea of an employee working hard now in hopes of a future promotion and raise.
How does getting into a good school or getting promoted to a better job have anything to do with death? Well, it is that forward looking that we're examining here, both student and employee are looking to what is to come or what they hope to become (where they hope to be) and acting accordingly to put themselves in the best position to reach their goals. Now if we were to expand that to the full spectrum of life, the ultimate inevitability that we can observe in this existence is physical death. We know we were born, we know we will die, we don't really know much about what happens afterwards and we're currently living out the in between. However, if we let what will happen tomorrow affect how we act and live today, all the more should we not let what is ultimately inevitable for all of us affect our lives?
We live in a world of action and reaction, cause and effect, deed and consequence, and so on and so forth. While a lot of time we spend studying where we come from (history), we need also to plan for where we are going and that plan will determine ultimately how we are to live. Let us again consider the situation of a student. Now, a student who aimed to be a doctor would not spend large chunks of time taking literature or discrete mathematics courses, of course not. Our student would take only the necessary courses to graduate and focus his/her studies on subjects that would aid in the pursuit of a career in the field of medicine, taking classes on biology, anatomy, perhaps even pharmacology, and the like. Likewise an aspiring engineer would not stop to study philosphy, anthropology, or history extraordinarily extensively, but would put more effort into the familiarizing himself/herself in the realms of physics, mathematics, and other related sciences (depending on the brand of engineering). As we can see, what we aim for in the future determines what we do here and now. If we aim for nothing, we do nothing. So if where we are going determines what we do now, where is our ultimate destination but death? So therefore, the question of what happens after we die becomes rather important in regards to the meaning of life and the purpose for which we live.
Now I'm not going to come out and claim to be any expert on any sort of theological matters, in this case, afterlife, but there are a few more commonly held views out there that I'd like to explore. To me, there are three major ways we can look at what happens after death; nothing, reincarnation, or heaven/hell. As with the question of where we come from (the ever lengthy debate between creationism and evolution) each of these make a profound impact on how we are to live, I would go as far to say as to what our purpose is. The difficulty in such a question (as simple as it seems on the surface) is that we aren't really certain about it, and there is no way we can be certain about it until we experience it for ourselves (that is, when we die). While there is a great degree of uncertainty, that is no reason to shy away from the question for its impact on how we live is so great we cannot address it quickly enough. Why must we address it quickly? Well simply put, because we could die in any given instant. Morbid, but true. Anyways, I digress, let us press onward.
When I consider the idea of nothingness, I realize it's a relatively difficult idea to really grasp. While conceptually I can kind of imagine the idea of there be nothing, absolutely nothing, it's not something I can easily say that I can imagine. There's a difference, it might seem like I'm contradicting myself, but there's a difference, I can imagine the idea of nothingness, but not really nothingness itself, I suppose the best way to put it would be, ideal versus experiential imagination, or something like that. Sorry for all these minor tangents, but since I generally write colloquially, I'd probably do the same thing if we were actually talking, this way, you can just go back and read everything instead of having me repeat it again.
Anyways, while the concept of nothingness after this life (or death, however you want to put it) seems reassuring in the sense that it's all just over, the more I think about it the more I realize it's a pretty scary concept. So what exactly is the implication of nothing after death? Well firstly, it means that everything here is the be-all-end-all to our existence. Some might agree with that. It just simply means make the most of each moment because this one life is all we have. However, it also means that ultimately, there is no consequence to any of our actions. Life becomes a series of things "you get away with" simply because consequences are only temporal things, there are none afterward, the ultimate consequence is death, and everyone dies anyways, so it's just a matter of how. So if you get to do whatever you want and no adverse consequence comes of it, then great, you've made the most. If for some reason, something bad befalls you, well, it just sucks to be you. Concepts of right and wrong, crime and justice, fairness and unfairness, well, they're pretty arbitrary then, since all's well if you do something "wrong" and get away with it, right? What's to govern that? Society? Okay, perhaps to some degree, but if someone gets away with it, then hey, there's nothing beyond that right? This is starting to get a little abstract, so I'm going to try to bring this discussion to another issue. Let's take the simple law of economics; nothing happens if people don't see an inherent benefit or gain from doing something. I paraphrased that a little, but that's the general gist of it. If that's the case, what reason do I have to sacrifice what I have now for the sake of people tomorrow? For example, going green. Beyond some warm fuzzy feeling, what do I get out of it? I'll be gone, and if there's nothing afterward, I'm sacrificing something (money, comfort, time, just to name a few examples) for no gain to myself, right? Maybe it'll all change when I have children, but if I remain single for the rest of my life, then what benefit do I get from helping people in the future? Well, if I spend enough money, maybe a place in the history books, but again, if there's nothing after life, what good is it? It's not like I'll somehow know if I get mentioned in some 7th grader's history class as some altruistic gentleman or not. It sort of reminded me of the character the Joker from the most recent Batman film The Dark Knight. If there is no consequence beyond death, then why not live as you please until you die? Okay, so maybe you want to live long and die peacefully, fine, but my point is this, the mob boss that dies peacefully in bed because the police never could convict him is the same as the doctor working pro-bono in Africa who succumbed to some disease because of the poor living conditions. They both died naturally, and they go... nowhere, they become nothing. Intuitively, we want to make a distinction, but why? One impacted more people? Well, how about this example, two families, classic rags to riches story, both the fathers were poor but each managed to become successful and wealthy and provide for his family and generations to come. The difference, one came about his wealth through honest hard labor, the other through illegitimate and illegal practices. Both pass away quietly and peacefully in their old age. So now that they're both dead, they're the same, nothing. Okay... so, if the thief steals and gets away with it ends up the same as the man who sweat and work for every single dollar of his paycheck, then why bother with niceties like justice and law and order. It's the same as an investment, high-risk, high reward, low-risk, low reward. Since there is no ultimate consequence, those that are willing to face death (like say suicide bombers), can't be wrong. Sure we can condemn their actions, but hey, what're you going to do about it? They became nothing, just like everyone else before them, and just like all of us will after them. The victim and the perpetrator are both the same. Nothing. Intuitively, that just seems wrong, intuition is there for a reason. While intuitively we want to answer the question "Do you want to be remembered poorly?" with a no, if nothing were to come after death, then, what does it matter if I am remembered at all? It's not like the more I'm remembered the more I'm less nothing. Then again, that could be speculation on my part, but if we simply cease to exist as soon as our physical body expires, then, what reason have we to believe that by the will of others we can come back into existence?
If we look next into the idea of reincarnation, we find that the issue of consequence and action addressed via the means of karmic retribution. Our mob boss above who got away with stealing money will then be subject to a worse life the next time around in the great wheel of reincarnation, perhaps he will become a pauper, perhaps he'll become reincarnated as some beast of some form or another, a lowlier being than that of a human. Certainly the idea of getting another life based on how you do in this one brings some sense of consequence to our actions, but there's also a certain sense of futility to it, as if there's no real goal in mind. A lot of proponents of reincarnation say that we as humans are striving to become one with everything and thereby nothing, as far as I understand it, but if we're to become nothing, isn't that really just the same as what we discussed above, just with more rules and a more convoluted method getting there. I'm not here to really get into a whole lot of theology though, let's discuss the idea that you get a "better" life the next time around for the "good" life that you live now. First and foremost, we need a definition of what is "good". I think inherently we all have a general sense of what it is, but then when it comes to some more conflicting issues (like helping someone at the expense of another) then what is "good"? However, that also is another issue regarding ethics and morals that I don't intend to cover here, so the second issue then is what is a "better" life? There really isn't any apt measurement of what is "better" or "worse" in terms of living. Certainly, those who can provide for themselves are generally considered to have "better" lives than those who are starving, but how far does it go with haves and have-nots? Are more riches, more fame, more prominence, more whatever, really indications of a better life? Are we to say that an upper-middle class family having luxury cars, a large 4 bedroom home, the ability to fund its children through Ivy League college education, parents successfully working prominent positions, but on the brink of divorce due to family strife, disagreements, and miscommunication really lead a better life than that of a lower-middle class single-income family living happily and quietly in a small 2 bedroom apartment? What makes one life better than the other? Which situation would you rather be in? Is it physical posessions or is it the state of mind? We see people both in prince and pauper like situations with both kinds of mindsets. If we were to go further with the idea of potential reincarnation into non-human creatures, how do we know that a dog or insect live "worse" lives than that of a person? It's impossible. While the idea of consequence is there, it's fairly arbitrary given reincarnation, it really poses more questions than it answers, while there is the idea of action and reaction, choice and consequence, there is not much in terms of rhyme or reason behind how it is applied, in other words, there's really no feasible way to arbitrarily assign what kind of life is better than another, it's just life.
Finally then, is this concept of an afterlife, a final reckoning siphoning out the people between the two planes, as we'll call them, heaven and hell. It serves to say that there is an ultimate judgment that determines our place after our place here on this world in this life. What is this heaven then? Well, I can't say for sure as I've never been there, but from what I can reason, it can't be anything we can imagine. Some would have heaven being nothing but wealth and a blissful life of doing nothing, I'm pretty sure there are a good number of people that pretty much live that sort of lifestyle here and now, so if heaven can be achieved on earth then what need do we have for it? However, regardless of what exactly it is, it addresses the issue of what happens after one dies, and it gives each person a purpose, that is, an ultimate consequence for his/her life. It gives each of us a direction to move towards, and that is why, intuitively it seems the most reasonable and feasible answer. As a final note, allow me to point to Pascal's Wager, while I don't necessarily endorse those who have a flippant attitude towards it, it is something to ponder. Pascal's Wager states, that if I believe in God and I'm wrong about it, and there's nothing after death, then nothing happens, the same thing happens to me as everybody else, but if I don't believe in God and I'm wrong, then the consequences are both dire and eternal. Something for us to ponder and think about.
So let's give a little context, where did I come up with the motivation to write on such a (seemingly) morbid subject? Well, a few of the youth kids I know from my church went to a conference called Worldview Academy, and during street evangelism sessions, one of the common lead-in questions used was this: "Where do you go after you die?". It's a question people don't often give much thought to, at least not when they're younger, yet it is a question of utmost importance in life. Perhaps I could say it's a matter of perspective, how? Well, in the sense that knowing the choices of where you end up is a good motivator of what you do now and how you go about doing it. An example of such would be someone studying hard now because he/she wishes to attend a better college/university in the future. It is that goal of the university, say an Ivy League versus a local community college, that pushes our student here to study. If perhaps that example doesn't ring home, it is also the idea of an employee working hard now in hopes of a future promotion and raise.
How does getting into a good school or getting promoted to a better job have anything to do with death? Well, it is that forward looking that we're examining here, both student and employee are looking to what is to come or what they hope to become (where they hope to be) and acting accordingly to put themselves in the best position to reach their goals. Now if we were to expand that to the full spectrum of life, the ultimate inevitability that we can observe in this existence is physical death. We know we were born, we know we will die, we don't really know much about what happens afterwards and we're currently living out the in between. However, if we let what will happen tomorrow affect how we act and live today, all the more should we not let what is ultimately inevitable for all of us affect our lives?
We live in a world of action and reaction, cause and effect, deed and consequence, and so on and so forth. While a lot of time we spend studying where we come from (history), we need also to plan for where we are going and that plan will determine ultimately how we are to live. Let us again consider the situation of a student. Now, a student who aimed to be a doctor would not spend large chunks of time taking literature or discrete mathematics courses, of course not. Our student would take only the necessary courses to graduate and focus his/her studies on subjects that would aid in the pursuit of a career in the field of medicine, taking classes on biology, anatomy, perhaps even pharmacology, and the like. Likewise an aspiring engineer would not stop to study philosphy, anthropology, or history extraordinarily extensively, but would put more effort into the familiarizing himself/herself in the realms of physics, mathematics, and other related sciences (depending on the brand of engineering). As we can see, what we aim for in the future determines what we do here and now. If we aim for nothing, we do nothing. So if where we are going determines what we do now, where is our ultimate destination but death? So therefore, the question of what happens after we die becomes rather important in regards to the meaning of life and the purpose for which we live.
Now I'm not going to come out and claim to be any expert on any sort of theological matters, in this case, afterlife, but there are a few more commonly held views out there that I'd like to explore. To me, there are three major ways we can look at what happens after death; nothing, reincarnation, or heaven/hell. As with the question of where we come from (the ever lengthy debate between creationism and evolution) each of these make a profound impact on how we are to live, I would go as far to say as to what our purpose is. The difficulty in such a question (as simple as it seems on the surface) is that we aren't really certain about it, and there is no way we can be certain about it until we experience it for ourselves (that is, when we die). While there is a great degree of uncertainty, that is no reason to shy away from the question for its impact on how we live is so great we cannot address it quickly enough. Why must we address it quickly? Well simply put, because we could die in any given instant. Morbid, but true. Anyways, I digress, let us press onward.
When I consider the idea of nothingness, I realize it's a relatively difficult idea to really grasp. While conceptually I can kind of imagine the idea of there be nothing, absolutely nothing, it's not something I can easily say that I can imagine. There's a difference, it might seem like I'm contradicting myself, but there's a difference, I can imagine the idea of nothingness, but not really nothingness itself, I suppose the best way to put it would be, ideal versus experiential imagination, or something like that. Sorry for all these minor tangents, but since I generally write colloquially, I'd probably do the same thing if we were actually talking, this way, you can just go back and read everything instead of having me repeat it again.
Anyways, while the concept of nothingness after this life (or death, however you want to put it) seems reassuring in the sense that it's all just over, the more I think about it the more I realize it's a pretty scary concept. So what exactly is the implication of nothing after death? Well firstly, it means that everything here is the be-all-end-all to our existence. Some might agree with that. It just simply means make the most of each moment because this one life is all we have. However, it also means that ultimately, there is no consequence to any of our actions. Life becomes a series of things "you get away with" simply because consequences are only temporal things, there are none afterward, the ultimate consequence is death, and everyone dies anyways, so it's just a matter of how. So if you get to do whatever you want and no adverse consequence comes of it, then great, you've made the most. If for some reason, something bad befalls you, well, it just sucks to be you. Concepts of right and wrong, crime and justice, fairness and unfairness, well, they're pretty arbitrary then, since all's well if you do something "wrong" and get away with it, right? What's to govern that? Society? Okay, perhaps to some degree, but if someone gets away with it, then hey, there's nothing beyond that right? This is starting to get a little abstract, so I'm going to try to bring this discussion to another issue. Let's take the simple law of economics; nothing happens if people don't see an inherent benefit or gain from doing something. I paraphrased that a little, but that's the general gist of it. If that's the case, what reason do I have to sacrifice what I have now for the sake of people tomorrow? For example, going green. Beyond some warm fuzzy feeling, what do I get out of it? I'll be gone, and if there's nothing afterward, I'm sacrificing something (money, comfort, time, just to name a few examples) for no gain to myself, right? Maybe it'll all change when I have children, but if I remain single for the rest of my life, then what benefit do I get from helping people in the future? Well, if I spend enough money, maybe a place in the history books, but again, if there's nothing after life, what good is it? It's not like I'll somehow know if I get mentioned in some 7th grader's history class as some altruistic gentleman or not. It sort of reminded me of the character the Joker from the most recent Batman film The Dark Knight. If there is no consequence beyond death, then why not live as you please until you die? Okay, so maybe you want to live long and die peacefully, fine, but my point is this, the mob boss that dies peacefully in bed because the police never could convict him is the same as the doctor working pro-bono in Africa who succumbed to some disease because of the poor living conditions. They both died naturally, and they go... nowhere, they become nothing. Intuitively, we want to make a distinction, but why? One impacted more people? Well, how about this example, two families, classic rags to riches story, both the fathers were poor but each managed to become successful and wealthy and provide for his family and generations to come. The difference, one came about his wealth through honest hard labor, the other through illegitimate and illegal practices. Both pass away quietly and peacefully in their old age. So now that they're both dead, they're the same, nothing. Okay... so, if the thief steals and gets away with it ends up the same as the man who sweat and work for every single dollar of his paycheck, then why bother with niceties like justice and law and order. It's the same as an investment, high-risk, high reward, low-risk, low reward. Since there is no ultimate consequence, those that are willing to face death (like say suicide bombers), can't be wrong. Sure we can condemn their actions, but hey, what're you going to do about it? They became nothing, just like everyone else before them, and just like all of us will after them. The victim and the perpetrator are both the same. Nothing. Intuitively, that just seems wrong, intuition is there for a reason. While intuitively we want to answer the question "Do you want to be remembered poorly?" with a no, if nothing were to come after death, then, what does it matter if I am remembered at all? It's not like the more I'm remembered the more I'm less nothing. Then again, that could be speculation on my part, but if we simply cease to exist as soon as our physical body expires, then, what reason have we to believe that by the will of others we can come back into existence?
If we look next into the idea of reincarnation, we find that the issue of consequence and action addressed via the means of karmic retribution. Our mob boss above who got away with stealing money will then be subject to a worse life the next time around in the great wheel of reincarnation, perhaps he will become a pauper, perhaps he'll become reincarnated as some beast of some form or another, a lowlier being than that of a human. Certainly the idea of getting another life based on how you do in this one brings some sense of consequence to our actions, but there's also a certain sense of futility to it, as if there's no real goal in mind. A lot of proponents of reincarnation say that we as humans are striving to become one with everything and thereby nothing, as far as I understand it, but if we're to become nothing, isn't that really just the same as what we discussed above, just with more rules and a more convoluted method getting there. I'm not here to really get into a whole lot of theology though, let's discuss the idea that you get a "better" life the next time around for the "good" life that you live now. First and foremost, we need a definition of what is "good". I think inherently we all have a general sense of what it is, but then when it comes to some more conflicting issues (like helping someone at the expense of another) then what is "good"? However, that also is another issue regarding ethics and morals that I don't intend to cover here, so the second issue then is what is a "better" life? There really isn't any apt measurement of what is "better" or "worse" in terms of living. Certainly, those who can provide for themselves are generally considered to have "better" lives than those who are starving, but how far does it go with haves and have-nots? Are more riches, more fame, more prominence, more whatever, really indications of a better life? Are we to say that an upper-middle class family having luxury cars, a large 4 bedroom home, the ability to fund its children through Ivy League college education, parents successfully working prominent positions, but on the brink of divorce due to family strife, disagreements, and miscommunication really lead a better life than that of a lower-middle class single-income family living happily and quietly in a small 2 bedroom apartment? What makes one life better than the other? Which situation would you rather be in? Is it physical posessions or is it the state of mind? We see people both in prince and pauper like situations with both kinds of mindsets. If we were to go further with the idea of potential reincarnation into non-human creatures, how do we know that a dog or insect live "worse" lives than that of a person? It's impossible. While the idea of consequence is there, it's fairly arbitrary given reincarnation, it really poses more questions than it answers, while there is the idea of action and reaction, choice and consequence, there is not much in terms of rhyme or reason behind how it is applied, in other words, there's really no feasible way to arbitrarily assign what kind of life is better than another, it's just life.
Finally then, is this concept of an afterlife, a final reckoning siphoning out the people between the two planes, as we'll call them, heaven and hell. It serves to say that there is an ultimate judgment that determines our place after our place here on this world in this life. What is this heaven then? Well, I can't say for sure as I've never been there, but from what I can reason, it can't be anything we can imagine. Some would have heaven being nothing but wealth and a blissful life of doing nothing, I'm pretty sure there are a good number of people that pretty much live that sort of lifestyle here and now, so if heaven can be achieved on earth then what need do we have for it? However, regardless of what exactly it is, it addresses the issue of what happens after one dies, and it gives each person a purpose, that is, an ultimate consequence for his/her life. It gives each of us a direction to move towards, and that is why, intuitively it seems the most reasonable and feasible answer. As a final note, allow me to point to Pascal's Wager, while I don't necessarily endorse those who have a flippant attitude towards it, it is something to ponder. Pascal's Wager states, that if I believe in God and I'm wrong about it, and there's nothing after death, then nothing happens, the same thing happens to me as everybody else, but if I don't believe in God and I'm wrong, then the consequences are both dire and eternal. Something for us to ponder and think about.
Wednesday, July 29, 2009
Mac vs PC
This has been a long-standing debate, that recently has been revived with the new purported "Mac revolution". I'm going to be completely honest here, I am a PC user, but I've used Macs and can appreciate the product that Apple puts onto the table. So the debate remains which is better, Macs or PC, which ultimately boils down to whether the Mac OS is better than Windows (though now that Macs can install Windows on them the it's not a huge issue). My longstanding position has been that Macs are inherently more stable (less prone to crash) and overall better for multimedia/artistic endeavors, whereas PC is just simply the more practical. While the proprietary software available with the Mac OS may be far superior to those offered by Windows; iMovie, iPhoto, iTunes, and GarageBand to Windows Movie Maker, Windows Picture Editor, Windows Media Player, and some proprietary Windows audio recording device, there are enough available freeware software that are equally if not more powerful than the basic software offered with either OS (Picasa, Winamp, and Audacity for example, leaving only a sufficiently powerful movie maker unavailable via freeware, at least as far as I know).
While it appears that more and more people are using Macs, and with the advent of the ever-popular "I'm a Mac, I'm a PC" commercials, Apple still remains fifth in the US computer market and is a non-factor in the global scheme of things. The problem for Apple? Simply put, they cost too much. What's the difference? Well, let's take a look:
Let's say we look at a standard 13" MacBook Pro, the specs are as follows:
2.26 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo processor
2GB memory
160GB 5400-rpm hard drive
NVIDIA GeForce 9400M graphics processor
1280x800 13.3-inch widescreen display
2 USB 2.0 ports
1 firewire 800 port
Mini display port
iSight camera
SD card input
I didn't include a lot of the physical builds of the Mac, but I hardly think that makes a significant difference. The price you pay for this is $1199, at least.
Now let's look at Dell, the number 2 producer, I pick Dell because I can pick specs to match as close as possible the specs the MacBook Pro has:
2.2 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo T6600
2GB shared dual channel DDR2
160GB 5400rpm hard drive
Intel Graphics Media Accelerator X3100
1280x800 13.3-inch widescreen display
2.0 megapixel camera
I'm not sure on the number of ports, if there's a firewire or SD port, but honestly, those are rather tertiary when deciding whether or not to get a laptop. That being said, this model ends up being $599.
So what in the MacBook Pro warrants doubling the price? Hardware-wise the only difference I see is possibly in the video card, where the Apple product has the superior NVIDIA GeForce card to the Intel graphics accelerator. While it's hard to price out laptop video card specs, the most expensive onboard desktop video card runs at $300, and I'm inclined to believe that it performs better than any integrated laptop graphics card, and even if Intel gave away it's integrated graphics card, it doesn't account for $600 price difference overall. So what's the other difference, well, if we consider the difference between the number of USB ports and the like are rather negligible (you can get convertors and hubs and the like for about $20 if you look hard enough), the only major difference then would be the OS.
Windows runs for anywhere between $100 and $200 depending on what you're looking for. Mac OSX runs for $99. Wait, what? So the Mac OS, at least on its own costs less than Windows? Hold on, how does that work? Well, for that we'd have to look a little into the construction of the computers themselves. The chipsets that are built for each computer company (that is, HP, Dell, Acer, Apple, Toshiba, Lenovo, etc...) are designed to be able to support a specific OS design. If you didn't know (don't try this) this is the reason why Mac OS cannot be installed onto any non-Apple computer. The chipset for Apple (now made by Intel) were specifically designed for the Mac OS (and more recently enabled to be Windows compatible) whereas the other PC chipsets are designed more generically with no specific OS in mind, though Windows is the primary use. What the chipset gains with versatility in the ability to work with Linux and Windows it loses out in the stability that an OS specific chipset (like those in Macs) provide. So in short, Mac OSX is completely useless to you except as a coaster unless you already own a Mac, which in turn is more expensive than its PC counterparts.
Now I'm not here to bash Macs, seriously, my point is this, it really depends on what you're trying to do. For the average layman/non-computer person, you're paying a hefty premium, almost double the price on basically everything (let's not even begin to discuss accessories) for a few less blue screens and forced system reboots, let's be honest with ourselves, that's about it. Some might pull out the argument that fewer people try to hack Macs and therefore you're less prone to viruses and worms and the like, but fewer hackers on Macs also entails fewer programmers on Macs, meaning a vastly smaller number of software compatibility. My point is simply this, figure out what you need your computer for. I'll admit that the Mac OS is sleeker and probably has a lower learning curve than that of Windows.
Since a lot of Mac users are PC converts, and if you're reading this, you're probably using a computer of some sort, this is my point, if it's worth it to you, to pay twice the amount of money and relearning a new OS for fewer blue screens and possibly crashes and forced restarts, then by all means, get a Mac. Most gamers probably already know this, but most games probably aren't Mac compatible, and if they are, the patches and updates for Macs are often released much later than the actual release. So who can use a Mac then? Well, as I mentioned earlier, one thing that improved OS stability definitely aids with, is multimedia projects. In my opinion, Macs are artists' computers, they have the graphics capacity and stability to make movie-making and special effects things that make Macs most effective, additionally, Apple also exclusively offers for Macs possibly the most powerful consumer movie-making software in Final Cut Pro (while I think Adobe CS series is good enough, that's another discussion for another time). Additionally, for the more amateur multimedia hobbyist, Mac software is much more friendly and versatile than the Windows equivalents (iMovie vs Windows Movie Maker), having an effective tool without having to look to a confusing third-party product (honestly, I haven't really used anything outside of iMovie or Adobe Premier that I've really liked).
I'm not going to get into the desktop discussion right now, because regardless of how nice a Mac is, people can always buy parts and make a better computer for cheaper if they feel so inclined for the performance. Since Microsoft makes the office software for both Macs and PCs nowadays anyways, the availability and compatibility of general work-related products (Word, Excel, PowerPoint) is fairly universal and doesn't really play into the argument. I'm not going to tell anyone to buy one or the other without hearing any more about his/her specific computer needs, but this is my take on the long over-drawn Mac versus PC discussion.
While it appears that more and more people are using Macs, and with the advent of the ever-popular "I'm a Mac, I'm a PC" commercials, Apple still remains fifth in the US computer market and is a non-factor in the global scheme of things. The problem for Apple? Simply put, they cost too much. What's the difference? Well, let's take a look:
Let's say we look at a standard 13" MacBook Pro, the specs are as follows:
2.26 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo processor
2GB memory
160GB 5400-rpm hard drive
NVIDIA GeForce 9400M graphics processor
1280x800 13.3-inch widescreen display
2 USB 2.0 ports
1 firewire 800 port
Mini display port
iSight camera
SD card input
I didn't include a lot of the physical builds of the Mac, but I hardly think that makes a significant difference. The price you pay for this is $1199, at least.
Now let's look at Dell, the number 2 producer, I pick Dell because I can pick specs to match as close as possible the specs the MacBook Pro has:
2.2 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo T6600
2GB shared dual channel DDR2
160GB 5400rpm hard drive
Intel Graphics Media Accelerator X3100
1280x800 13.3-inch widescreen display
2.0 megapixel camera
I'm not sure on the number of ports, if there's a firewire or SD port, but honestly, those are rather tertiary when deciding whether or not to get a laptop. That being said, this model ends up being $599.
So what in the MacBook Pro warrants doubling the price? Hardware-wise the only difference I see is possibly in the video card, where the Apple product has the superior NVIDIA GeForce card to the Intel graphics accelerator. While it's hard to price out laptop video card specs, the most expensive onboard desktop video card runs at $300, and I'm inclined to believe that it performs better than any integrated laptop graphics card, and even if Intel gave away it's integrated graphics card, it doesn't account for $600 price difference overall. So what's the other difference, well, if we consider the difference between the number of USB ports and the like are rather negligible (you can get convertors and hubs and the like for about $20 if you look hard enough), the only major difference then would be the OS.
Windows runs for anywhere between $100 and $200 depending on what you're looking for. Mac OSX runs for $99. Wait, what? So the Mac OS, at least on its own costs less than Windows? Hold on, how does that work? Well, for that we'd have to look a little into the construction of the computers themselves. The chipsets that are built for each computer company (that is, HP, Dell, Acer, Apple, Toshiba, Lenovo, etc...) are designed to be able to support a specific OS design. If you didn't know (don't try this) this is the reason why Mac OS cannot be installed onto any non-Apple computer. The chipset for Apple (now made by Intel) were specifically designed for the Mac OS (and more recently enabled to be Windows compatible) whereas the other PC chipsets are designed more generically with no specific OS in mind, though Windows is the primary use. What the chipset gains with versatility in the ability to work with Linux and Windows it loses out in the stability that an OS specific chipset (like those in Macs) provide. So in short, Mac OSX is completely useless to you except as a coaster unless you already own a Mac, which in turn is more expensive than its PC counterparts.
Now I'm not here to bash Macs, seriously, my point is this, it really depends on what you're trying to do. For the average layman/non-computer person, you're paying a hefty premium, almost double the price on basically everything (let's not even begin to discuss accessories) for a few less blue screens and forced system reboots, let's be honest with ourselves, that's about it. Some might pull out the argument that fewer people try to hack Macs and therefore you're less prone to viruses and worms and the like, but fewer hackers on Macs also entails fewer programmers on Macs, meaning a vastly smaller number of software compatibility. My point is simply this, figure out what you need your computer for. I'll admit that the Mac OS is sleeker and probably has a lower learning curve than that of Windows.
Since a lot of Mac users are PC converts, and if you're reading this, you're probably using a computer of some sort, this is my point, if it's worth it to you, to pay twice the amount of money and relearning a new OS for fewer blue screens and possibly crashes and forced restarts, then by all means, get a Mac. Most gamers probably already know this, but most games probably aren't Mac compatible, and if they are, the patches and updates for Macs are often released much later than the actual release. So who can use a Mac then? Well, as I mentioned earlier, one thing that improved OS stability definitely aids with, is multimedia projects. In my opinion, Macs are artists' computers, they have the graphics capacity and stability to make movie-making and special effects things that make Macs most effective, additionally, Apple also exclusively offers for Macs possibly the most powerful consumer movie-making software in Final Cut Pro (while I think Adobe CS series is good enough, that's another discussion for another time). Additionally, for the more amateur multimedia hobbyist, Mac software is much more friendly and versatile than the Windows equivalents (iMovie vs Windows Movie Maker), having an effective tool without having to look to a confusing third-party product (honestly, I haven't really used anything outside of iMovie or Adobe Premier that I've really liked).
I'm not going to get into the desktop discussion right now, because regardless of how nice a Mac is, people can always buy parts and make a better computer for cheaper if they feel so inclined for the performance. Since Microsoft makes the office software for both Macs and PCs nowadays anyways, the availability and compatibility of general work-related products (Word, Excel, PowerPoint) is fairly universal and doesn't really play into the argument. I'm not going to tell anyone to buy one or the other without hearing any more about his/her specific computer needs, but this is my take on the long over-drawn Mac versus PC discussion.
Friday, March 13, 2009
Something bothering me about Superbowl ad
Sorry haven't posted anything here for a while... if you watched the Superbowl, however long ago it was, you probably vaguely remember an Audi commercial starring Jason Statham (see below) where it's like The Transporter and he gets into a bunch of cars trying to get away from other people. If nothing else, Jason Statham is known as the action guy with a lot of cool if unrealistic driving scenes. Now if you notice, he gets first into a Mercedes-Benz, then later he jacks someone's BMW. Now, maybe it's me, but does it bother anyone else that he refuses to even get into the Lexus (the only Japanese car in the commercial)? Then gets into the Audi and gets away clean. I mean, maybe it wouldn't have been a big deal if it had been like a Peugeot or something (ok so it's a commercial in America, and Americans don't drive Peugeots, but you get my point), or even like a Volkswagon (ok, not really in the same "class" of cars, being more of an economy brand). Maybe I'm reading too much into this, but then I remember the quote, "Nothing goes into commercial advertising on accident." Audi doesn't like Lexus?
Monday, December 15, 2008
Contemporary Influences in "Classical" music?
So I had been listening to KDFC (the Bay Area classical station) for a little bit and they introduced me to a modern Italian composer named Ludovico Einaudi. Einaudi's compositional style actually reminds me a little of George Winston, who I don't really construe as "classical", but since the station thinks it is (I guess he does more chamber stuff?) we call it that. Einaudi does all forms of composition but I think primarily does piano stuff with maybe some strings on the side. When I first heard a Ludovico Einaudi song though, I was reminded not of classical, but of a rather modern pop song... Perhaps Einaudi enjoys listening to that sort of thing...? Dunno. You see for yourself.
Pay attention to the main theme at 0:38, though it recurs throughout the piece. Now compare:
Pay attention to the intro...
Maybe it's me, but the resemblence is uncanny.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)